User Tools

Site Tools


playground:faq:other_transmit_power_issues

Differences

This shows you the differences between two versions of the page.

Link to this comparison view

playground:faq:other_transmit_power_issues [2018/07/08 18:51] (current)
tmomas created
Line 1: Line 1:
 +====== Other transmit power issues ======
 +
 +**Issues:**
 +  * The reg domain allow 23 dBm (correctly set) while I'm unable to go above 16 dBm
 +  * My router is transmitting below the allowed power output of my country
 +  * I can only set low transmission power, OEM firmware allowed me to set higher values
 +  * I have strange tx power limits
 +
 +
 +**Root causes + solutions:​**
 +
 +1. Regulatory data might be outdated or wrong
 +
 +Fix regulatory bugs and report them to OpenWrt and/or upstream at: http://​lists.infradead.org/​pipermail/​wireless-regdb
 +
 +<​code>​
 +iw reg get</​code>​
 +
 +2. Hardware is not constructed or does not support high transmission power
 +
 +2.a Hardware design (target market) plays a role
 +
 +High tx power requires different hardware design (more costs not worth on consumer hardware). Most use cases do not need high tx power but can profit from better antenna or multiple APs.
 +
 +
 +2.b Hardware limits
 +
 +see Background-1 & MCS ratings w. tx power on data sheets (example: [[https://​wikidevi.com/​files/​datasheets/​compex/​wlm200n5-23esd.pdf|WLM200N-23ESD]]).
 +Setting higher limits can damage or shorten the lifespan of the hardware.
 +Hardware quality varies in production process and individual calibration is costly.
 +Use high tx power cards if you need them or can operate them in your regulatory domain. Some regulators might allow operation for radio amateur or via some license scheme.
 +
 +3. Driver/​Implementation limitations
 +
 +The driver does not use some circuitry (on RX path: [[wp>​Low-noise_amplifier|LNA]],​ [[https://​git.lede-project.org/?​p=source.git;​a=commit;​h=94e23bf7409d6cc4c9efb55ed32aba8e5a497966|example]])
 +Factory firmware, OpenWrt and some vendor firmware based on OpenWrt could use different drivers.
 +Each driver can interpret limits differently. Without measuring equipment the output power level could be reported wrong. Power management can influence neighbour APs (noise floor,​hidden station).
 +
 +4. Firmware/​ART/​caldata/​EEPROM/​OTP limitations
 +
 +"​Firmware"​ means the blobs loaded by fullmac devices (many 802.11ac chipsets) can introduce non changeable tx power or different tx power depending on driver.
 +
 +"​ART/​caldata"​ means a dedicated partition on system flash containing data to setup ath9k (ART=atheros radio test) or other hardware (caldata = calibration data).
 +
 +[[wp>​EEPROM|"​EEPROM"​]] means a dedicated chip contains the setup data (common on older devices).
 +
 +[[wp>​One-time_programmable|"​OTP"​]] means the data for the setup is inside the main wlan chip.
 +
 +Many countries enforce conformity tests (FCC, CE...) to ensure that the hardware operates within reasonable limits. Doing these conformity tests is often not done on very cheap hardware or the hardware is programmed and designed to operate at save values instead of operating at the "​regulation border"​ at max. allowed txpower.
 +**Some regulation infos can be part of the ART/​caldata/​EEPROM/​OTP.**
 +
 +Some devices contain multiple ARTs. Using high power tables can damage the device - see [[https://​git.lede-project.org/?​p=source.git;​a=commit;​h=c2e0c41842895ba47819fa98b785c76a2524628b|this commit]]
 +
 +
 +{{tag>​faq wireless wireless_power}}
  
playground/faq/other_transmit_power_issues.txt · Last modified: 2018/07/08 18:51 by tmomas